

An 18th-century Scottish historian whose dramatic shifts between Catholicism and Protestantism made his life story more debated than his writings.
Archibald Bower's life reads like a theological thriller, marked by defections, recantations, and public controversy. Born in Scotland, he was educated as a Jesuit in Rome but dramatically left the Catholic faith, converting to Anglicanism and later becoming a Presbyterian. He settled in England and embarked on his major work, a multi-volume 'History of the Popes,' which was met with fierce criticism from Catholic writers who attacked his credibility. His opponents published detailed accounts accusing him of secretly remaining a Catholic, leading to a protracted and bitter public war of pamphlets. Modern scholars generally view his personal narratives with skepticism, seeing them as unreliable. Bower's historical significance lies less in his scholarly output and more in his embodiment of the fierce religious polemics of his age.
The biggest hits of 1686
The world at every milestone
He was once a Jesuit, studying at the Collegium Romanum in Rome.
Bower was a founding contributor to the 'Monthly Review', an influential early literary journal.
He faced a lawsuit for libel from a critic of his 'History of the Popes'.
“I write history not to please a party, but to follow the evidence wherever it leads.”